MTG Arena is a complex game. Keeping track of your deck, opponent cards, and win rates in your head is nearly impossible. That is why deck trackers are essential.
Two of the most well-known names in the community are MTGATracker and Untapped.gg. While one has evolved into an industry giant, the other holds a historic place in the game’s community.
Here is a direct comparison to help you choose the right tool for your gameplay. The Contenders at a Glance
Untapped.gg: The current market leader. It features a sleek user interface, automated in-game overlays, comprehensive draft companions, and massive global meta-game statistics.
MTGATracker: One of the earliest open-source trackers for MTG Arena. It focused on lightweight, privacy-focused, local deck tracking.
Note: MTGATracker was a community favorite during the early years of MTG Arena, but active development has largely ceased. Untapped.gg has become the standard active software for modern players. In-Game Overlay and Features Untapped.gg
Untapped.gg excels at providing real-time, actionable information while you play.
Deck Tracking: Shows your remaining library and the exact draw percentages for every card.
Opponent Tracking: Lists all cards your opponent has revealed or played so far.
Draft Companion: Displays limited ratings and card commentary directly on the screen during drafts. MTGATracker MTGATracker offered a minimalist approach to the overlay. Clean Look: A basic, no-frills list of your deck contents.
Log Parsing: Read local log files to show what cards were left in your deck.
Customization: Allowed users to tweak themes via open-source code, though it lacked modern visual polish. Meta-Game Statistics and Web Dashboard Untapped.gg The web platform is where Untapped.gg truly dominates.
Personal Profile: Tracks your win rates by format, deck, color identity, and play/draw status.
Global Meta Data: Aggregates millions of matches to show the best-performing decks in Standard, Alchemy, Explorer, and Historic.
Premium Tier: Offers advanced filters for specific ranks (e.g., Mythic-only data) behind a monthly subscription. MTGATracker MTGATracker relied on a companion website called Inspector. History: Tracked basic win/loss records and game logs.
Limitations: The web infrastructure was scaled back as development slowed, making it obsolete compared to modern data engines. Performance and Privacy Untapped.gg
Pros: Highly optimized, syncs instantly with cloud servers, and updates automatically after every MTG Arena patch.
Cons: Closed-source software that collects gameplay data to build its global statistical models. MTGATracker
Pros: Completely open-source and free. Your data belongs to you, appeals to privacy-conscious players, and consumes minimal system resources.
Cons: Prone to breaking when MTG Arena updates its internal log formats, requiring manual community fixes. The Verdict: Which is Best? There is a clear winner for modern players.
Choose Untapped.gg if you want a reliable, actively updated, feature-rich companion. It is the best tool for ranking up, drafting efficiently, and analyzing the current meta.
Choose MTGATracker only if you are a developer looking to experiment with open-source project code, or if you prefer entirely offline, basic tracking. For standard gameplay, its lack of recent updates makes it difficult to run seamlessly today.
If you want to dive deeper into optimizing your setup, let me know:
Which formats you play most (e.g., Standard, Premier Draft, Historic)
Whether you prefer free tools or are open to premium subscriptions
I can recommend the exact settings or alternative tools to maximize your win rate. Saved time Comprehensive Inappropriate Not working
A copy of this chat, including the images and video, will be included with your feedback A copy of this chat will be included with your feedback
Your feedback will include a copy of this chat and the image from your search
Your feedback will include a copy of this chat, any links you shared, and the image from your search.
Thanks for letting us know
Google may use account and system data to understand your feedback and improve our services, subject to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service. For legal issues, make a legal removal request.